In the first survey, nearly 70% of Americans said they would be likely to support a well-funded, independent candidate who shared their views and was willing to work across the aisle. Only about 6% said they actually planned to vote for an independent candidate in their own district — a gap between stated openness and expected behavior that has remained a consistent feature of the data.
In the second wave, that overall pattern held steady: 70.8% of respondents expressed openness to a strong independent candidate (statistically unchanged from 69.5%), and the share planning to vote independent on the generic ballot remained at 6.3%, identical to the first wave.
While most top-line numbers were stable between waves, one subgroup shifted measurably. Openness to a strong independent candidate among Republican respondents rose from 62.7% to 70.3%, a 7.6-point increase — the largest movement recorded anywhere in the poll. This shift met standard thresholds for statistical significance (p ≈ 0.04) and appeared consistently across both "very likely" and "somewhat likely" response categories.
In the first wave, Republican respondents showed comparatively less openness to an independent alternative than Democratic or independent-identifying respondents. In the second wave, that gap narrowed considerably: Independents (76%), Democrats (72%), and Republicans (70%) were separated by only six percentage points — a much more even distribution across party lines than in the earlier survey.
The survey data points to two consistent factors behind the difference between stated openness (70%) and expected voting behavior (6%):
Neither of these dynamics shifted meaningfully between survey waves, which researchers note is consistent with the stability seen in the overall 6% voting-intent figure.
Between the two waves, several other indicators moved modestly: self-reported party identification shifted slightly toward Republicans, and presidential approval ratings declined to approximately 39% approve / 57% disapprove. The generic congressional ballot showed Democrats at 42% and Republicans at 37%, with independent-candidate support unchanged at 6.3%.
Across two survey waves, the data shows a large and durable pool of Americans open to independent candidates, alongside a persistently small share who currently plan to vote that way. The most notable development between waves was a significant increase in openness among Republican respondents, which brought the three partisan groups closer together than in the earlier survey. Awareness of specific candidates and perceptions of vote-splitting remain largely unchanged and continue to be cited as the primary factors separating stated openness from expected voting behavior.
Methodology: Based on two national surveys of 1,000 U.S. adults each (Wave 2: 90.6% registered voters). Estimated margin of error ±3.1 percentage points; subgroup and wave-over-wave differences carry larger margins of error. Figures reflect the data as supplied.