Independent voters disapprove of how ICE has carried out immigration enforcement by wide margins, but that doesn't mean they want enforcement scaled back. On the specific policy questions behind the headlines, independents are close to evenly split, a position that neither party's immigration messaging accounts for. That gap, between broad disapproval of tactics and real support for enforcement in principle, is why independents remain the hardest group for either party to predict on this issue heading into the 2026 midterms.
A Quinnipiac University poll released July 29, 2026 found that 67% of independents disapproved of the job Immigration and Customs Enforcement was doing, compared with 78% of Republicans who approved and 94% of Democrats who disapproved. A New York Times/Siena College poll from January 2026 found a nearly identical pattern months earlier, with 70% of independents disapproving of how ICE was handling its job.
Sources: Quinnipiac University poll (July 2026); The New York Times/Siena College poll (January 2026).
Gallup polling found voters nearly evenly divided on whether to hire significantly more Border Patrol agents, with 49% in support and 48% opposed. That split suggests many independents support immigration enforcement in principle while objecting to specific tactics, a nuance that gets lost when either party talks about independents as a bloc.
Source: Gallup (2026).
The same Quinnipiac poll found that 49% of independents said they were more motivated to participate in the 2026 midterms than in previous midterm cycles. Immigration is one of the issues keeping independents engaged even when their actual views don't map onto either party's position.
Source: Quinnipiac University poll (July 2026).
What do independents think about ICE's job performance?
Independents disapprove of ICE's handling of enforcement by wide margins, 67% in a July 2026 Quinnipiac poll and 70% in a January 2026 New York Times/Siena College poll, far closer to Democrats than to Republicans on this specific question.
Do independents want immigration enforcement reduced overall?
Not necessarily. On specific enforcement proposals, like hiring more Border Patrol agents, independents are close to evenly split, which suggests disapproval of particular tactics rather than opposition to enforcement itself.
Why does this matter for the 2026 midterms?
Because independents aren't a predictable bloc for either party on immigration, and a meaningful share say the issue is part of why they're more motivated to vote this cycle than in past midterms.
Does the Independent Center take a position on immigration enforcement policy?
No. The Independent Center tracks what independent voters actually believe rather than advocating for a specific enforcement policy, since that view often doesn't match what either party assumes independents think.
If you want to see more research like this on where independents actually stand, sign up for our newsletter. And if you believe independent voices deserve a seat separate from both parties' talking points, consider a donation to help us keep doing this work.
.svg)